I’m not sure whether it’s because my birthday is getting closer, but we received the fantastic opportunity to have this article sponsored by one of the fastest growing startup companies globally: Notion. Therefore, we decided to give to all YAINers free access to this analysis, also to give you the opportunity to see first hand our thought process behind an investment and then decide whether to become a supporter. 

Get Over $6K of Notion Free with Unlimited AI

Running a startup is complex. That's why thousands of startups trust Notion as their connected workspace for managing projects, tracking fundraising, and team collaboration

Apply now to get up to 6 months of Notion with unlimited AI free ($6,000+ value) to build and scale your company with one tool. 

Get Free Notion + AI

Introduction

Vidrala is a significant European manufacturer of glass containers, primarily serving the food and beverage industries. Established in Spain in 1965, the company has evolved through organic growth, technological innovation, and strategic acquisitions, most notably the Encirc operations in the UK and Ireland, which added integrated filling and logistics services. More recently, Vidrala has expanded into the Brazilian market and undertaken strategic divestments in Europe to refocus its portfolio on core, profitable regions.

Vidrala S.A. stands out as a well-managed and resilient player in the stable container glass industry, holding strong market positions in key European regions and establishing a promising foothold in Brazil. The company has a solid track record of prudent capital allocation, consistent profitability, and a commitment to shareholder returns. From a YAIN standpoint, Vidrala's intrinsic quality, coupled with a disciplined approach to operational efficiency and strategic growth, warrants careful consideration, particularly if the market offers an adequate margin of safety.

Understanding the business

Vidrala's journey began in 1965 in Llodio, Álava, Spain, under the name Vidrierías de Álava S.A., with an initial production capacity of 25,000 tonnes per year.¹ From its inception, the company demonstrated a forward-thinking approach, particularly in technology. A pivotal moment was the adoption of the press-blow technique in 1977 for manufacturing lighter-weight bottles. This innovation provided a significant technological edge in the Spanish market, enabling nationwide expansion and reducing transportation costs, a critical factor in the glass industry. This early embrace of efficiency and market differentiation set a precedent for Vidrala's operational philosophy.

Vidrala's primary business is the manufacture of glass containers—bottles and jars—for a diverse range of food and beverage products. The company produces over 9 billion containers annually, serving as a critical packaging supplier.

A key differentiator for Vidrala, particularly through its Encirc operations in the UK and Ireland, is its integrated service offering. Beyond glass manufacturing, the company provides extensive logistic solutions and beverage filling activities. This "360-degree business model" allows Vidrala to offer customers a comprehensive "route to market" solution, from container design and manufacturing to filling, warehousing, and dispatch.² This integrated approach can create significant value for customers by simplifying their supply chains, reducing complexity, and potentially lowering overall costs, leading to stronger, more resilient customer relationships. The acquisition of "The Park," a beverage packaging and logistics business in Bristol, UK, from Accolade Wines in 2022 (announced, completed 2023) further enhances this integrated service capability.

Vidrala has consistently demonstrated a commitment to technological advancement. The company was an early adopter of RFID technology in its warehouses for enhanced traceability and has incorporated robotics and big data analytics into its processes, even before "Industry 4.0" became a widely recognized concept. Furthermore, Vidrala holds a worldwide patent for a technology that measures the capacity of containers without using water, a method described as quick and economical. This sustained focus on technological innovation is vital for maintaining operational excellence and cost efficiency in a capital-intensive industry.

Vidrala caters to a broad spectrum of the food and beverage industry, serving over 1,600 customers. This customer base includes a solid balance of blue-chip multinational brand owners and domestic packagers. The pro-forma sales breakdown by product segment for 2023 illustrates a well-diversified end-market exposure: Wine (32%), Beer (29%), Spirits (12%), Food (8%), Soft Drinks (9%), and Others (10%). 

This diversification mitigates the risk of over-reliance on any single category, providing a degree of resilience against segment-specific downturns or shifts in consumer preferences. For instance, changes in wine consumption patterns could potentially be offset by trends in the beer or spirits markets. The product mix also offers a balance between potentially higher-margin premium segments (like spirits and some wines) and higher-volume segments (like beer). While the top 10 customers account for approximately 35% of revenue, and around 20 customers make up 50% of sales, indicating significant relationships with key clients, this level of concentration also presents a risk that requires ongoing monitoring and management through strong customer service and value delivery. Historically, Vidrala was also a leading Spanish manufacturer of bottles for olive oil.

The Container Glass Industry

The European Glass Bottles and Containers Market, a core operational area for Vidrala, was valued at USD 24 billion in 2023. Projections indicate growth to USD 35 billion by 2031, reflecting a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 4.8% from 2024 to 2031.³ This moderate but steady growth trajectory points to a mature industry that continues to offer expansion opportunities. For a YAINer, such predictable demand can be more attractive than the volatility associated with high-growth, less established sectors.

While European demand is characterized as mature and stable, markets like Brazil, where Vidrala has recently expanded, offer more dynamic growth prospects. The broader economic significance of the container glass industry is substantial. In the European Union, glass-packaged goods accounted for over €140 billion in exports in 2023, representing 5.7% of all EU exports.⁴ High-value EU products such as champagne, spirits, and pharmaceuticals frequently rely on glass packaging, underscoring its strategic importance. This intrinsic link to key export sectors suggests a degree of underlying support for the industry, potentially through favorable recycling infrastructure development and policies that promote glass usage.

The container glass industry is characterized by significant barriers to entry, which protect incumbent players like Vidrala from a constant influx of new competitors:

• High Capital Intensity: Glass manufacturing is a continuous, 24/7/365 operation that requires substantial upfront investment in furnaces and related machinery, as well as ongoing capital for periodic rebuilds and technological upgrades.

• Local Sales Nature: The physical characteristics of glass containers (heavy and fragile) limit the economical distance over which they can be transported. This inherently local or regional nature of sales favors manufacturers with strategically located plants close to their customer base, creating regional competitive advantages or economic moats.

• Operating Gearing and Economies of Scale: The high fixed costs associated with running glass furnaces mean that high plant utilization rates are crucial for profitability. This creates a significant operating leverage effect and benefits larger players who can achieve economies of scale in production and procurement.

• Energy Costs: The production process is highly energy-intensive, making energy prices a critical cost component and a source of volatility.

These barriers collectively contribute to a relatively stable industry structure. However, the industry also faces challenges, including the complexity of manufacturing high-quality glass containers efficiently and managing the logistical constraints associated with a fragile product. Competition exists not only among glass manufacturers but, to some extent, from alternative packaging materials, although glass's sustainability profile provides a growing advantage.

Economic Moat and Market Positioning

Vidrala has established itself as one of the principal glass container manufacturers in Western Europe. Its market strength is particularly evident in specific regions:

• Iberia (Spain & Portugal): Vidrala is recognized as the market leader in the Iberian Peninsula. This leadership was significantly solidified by the acquisition of Santos Barosa in Portugal in 2017. A dominant position in its home market provides a stable foundation, offering benefits such as economies of scale in regional procurement and logistics, and strong, long-standing customer relationships. The financial resilience of this segment, as demonstrated in Q1 2025 results where Iberia & Rest of EU operations saw an 11% increase in EBITDA despite a 4% sales decline, underscores the strength derived from this market leadership.

• UK & Ireland: Through its subsidiary Encirc, acquired in 2015, Vidrala holds a co-leading position in the British market and is the sole glass container manufacturer in Ireland. At the time of acquisition, Encirc's market share in the UK was estimated at around 27-30%. The status as the only producer in Ireland confers a particularly strong competitive advantage, effectively creating a local monopoly. This strong positioning in the UK and Ireland is further enhanced by Encirc's integrated service model.

• Brazil: The acquisition of Vidroporto in 2023 marked Vidrala's strategic entry into the Brazilian market. While a newer venture, the aim is to leverage Vidroporto's existing operations to tap into a market with higher growth potential than mature European economies and to strengthen relationships with global beverage customers operating in the region.

Vidrala operates in a competitive landscape populated by large, well-capitalized global players. 

Understanding these competitors is crucial for assessing Vidrala's relative strengths and challenges.⁵

• O-I Glass Inc. (Owens-Illinois): A formidable global competitor, O-I Glass is the largest manufacturer of glass containers in North America, South America, Asia-Pacific, and Europe (following its 2004 acquisition of BSN Glasspack). With revenues of $7.1 billion and approximately 23,000 employees, O-I has a substantial presence across Europe, including numerous production facilities in key countries like France, Germany, Italy, and Spain.

• Verallia: Identifying itself as the European leader and the world's third-largest producer of glass packaging for beverages and food products, Verallia is a direct and significant competitor. The company has a strong manufacturing footprint, particularly in France, Spain, Italy, and Germany. Verallia's strategic move to acquire Vidrala's Italian operations in 2024 further consolidated its position in that market. For FY2024, Verallia reported revenues of €3.46 billion and an adjusted EBITDA of €842 million.

• Ardagh Group: A global leader in both glass and metal packaging, Ardagh Group possesses significant glass manufacturing operations across Europe and North America. Its scale and diversified packaging offerings make it a major force in the industry.

• BA Glass Group: This privately owned company, headquartered in Portugal, has a considerable European presence, including operations in Spain and Bulgaria, making it a key competitor, particularly in the Iberian region.

The presence of such large competitors necessitates Vidrala's continuous focus on operational efficiency, innovation, and customer service to maintain and grow its market share. Scale is increasingly important in this industry, as evidenced by the ongoing trend of consolidation. Vidrala's ability to compete effectively and generate sustainable returns stems from several sources of competitive advantage:

• Scale and Market Leadership in Core Regions: As noted, leadership in Iberia and a strong co-leading position (including a monopoly in Ireland via Encirc) in the UK & Ireland provide significant economies of scale in procurement, manufacturing, and distribution, along with enhanced bargaining power with customers and suppliers within these territories.

• Integrated Service Offering (Encirc): The "360-degree solution" encompassing glass manufacturing, beverage filling, and logistics services offered by Encirc is a powerful differentiator in the UK and Irish markets. This integrated model creates high switching costs for customers who benefit from a simplified and efficient supply chain, fostering strong customer loyalty and a less price-sensitive relationship. It is a difficult model for competitors focused solely on glass manufacturing to replicate.

• Technological Expertise and Operational Efficiency: Vidrala's historical and ongoing commitment to technological innovation—from pioneering lightweight bottles to implementing advanced manufacturing execution systems, RFID, and patented measurement technologies—contributes to operational efficiency and cost competitiveness. In a capital-intensive industry with continuous processes, such efficiencies are vital for margin protection and expansion.

• Customer Relationships and Proximity: Long-standing relationships with major food and beverage brands, including blue-chip multinationals, are a testament to Vidrala's reliability and service quality. The localized nature of the glass packaging business, driven by logistical constraints, means that Vidrala's strategically located production facilities offer customers advantages in terms of timely supply and reduced transportation costs.

• Industry Barriers to Entry: The inherent characteristics of the glass container industry, including high capital requirements, the necessity for continuous production to achieve cost efficiencies, and the localized nature of sales, protect established players like Vidrala from widespread new competition. These barriers contribute to a more stable competitive environment for those who have already achieved scale and operational proficiency.

Growth

Vidrala has demonstrated consistent revenue growth over the period, from €1.01 billion in 2019 to €1.59 billion in 2024. The growth in 2023 was particularly strong at +15.3% on a constant currency and comparable scope basis, while 2024 saw more modest underlying growth of +0.2%, reflecting a softer demand environment offset by the full-year consolidation of Vidroporto and divestment of Italy.

As you know we are not big fans of EBITDA, but we reported this metric as it often comes up in Vidrala’s earning calls.

Profitability

A thorough examination of Vidrala's financial history and current standing is essential to gauge its operational effectiveness, profitability, capital efficiency, and overall financial health.

Vidrala has consistently generated strong ROCE, ROIC, and ROC. ROCE has generally been around or above 15-20%, and ROIC in the mid-teens. These figures, typically exceeding the company's weighted average cost of capital, indicate effective value creation for shareholders and suggest a business with a durable competitive advantage.

The company has managed its leverage prudently. Net Debt/EBITDA rose to 1.1x in 2023 following the Vidroporto acquisition but was swiftly reduced to 0.6x by the end of 2024 and stood at 0.7x in Q1 2025. This conservative leverage provides financial flexibility for future investments or to weather economic uncertainties. The strong interest coverage ratios further underscore this financial stability.

  Vidrala has demonstrated a strong ability to convert profits into cash.

Operating Cash Flow (OCF): OCF was €263.4 million in 2023 and rose to €362.5 million in 2024.

Free Cash Flow (FCF): After a dip in 2022, FCF generation recovered strongly to €153.5 million in 2023 and €206.0 million in 2024 (representing 13% of sales). The outlook for FY2025 is for FCF of approximately €200 million. This robust FCF generation is crucial for funding dividends, share buybacks, debt reduction, and reinvestment in the business.

Capital Expenditures (Capex): Vidrala is currently in a phase of "ambitious industrial investments", with capex guided to be around 12% of sales in FY2025. While this temporarily constrains FCF, these investments are aimed at enhancing long-term competitiveness, efficiency, and sustainability. The historical capex was €134.5 million in 2023.

Shareholder Remuneration

Vidrala employs a multi-faceted approach to returning capital to shareholders, combining regular dividends with opportunistic share buybacks and bonus share issues (effectively stock splits/dividends).

Share Buybacks: The company has executed several share repurchase programs over the years. For instance, in 2014, €6.1 million was allocated to buybacks.⁶ More recently, a program in 2022 led to the redemption of treasury shares, and another was completed in 2024, where €31.8 million was used to acquire and amortize 330,000 shares, thereby increasing earnings per share. The amortization of repurchased shares is particularly beneficial as it permanently reduces the share count. Management indicated no share buybacks are planned for 2025, possibly due to current valuations or other capital priorities like the ongoing capex program.

Dividends: Vidrala has a consistent and growing dividend policy, supplemented by special distributions like the one following the Italian divestment. The company has a track record of consistent dividend payments and the dividend yield has typically been in the 1.3% to 1.6% range. The dividend payout ratio (based on net income) appears sustainable, around 17%.

Bonus Share Issues: Vidrala has also periodically implemented bonus share issues (e.g., 2021, 2022, 2023, 2024). While these do not return cash directly, they can improve trading liquidity. In previous years, for every 20 shares owned by someone, Vidrala allocated one extra share.

Risks

While Vidrala possesses many attractive qualities, a comprehensive investment analysis must also consider the potential risks that could impact its performance and valuation.

Operational Risks

Energy Costs: The manufacture of glass is an energy-intensive process, heavily reliant on natural gas and electricity. Fluctuations in energy prices represent a significant operational risk, directly impacting production costs and margins. Vidrala mitigates this through long-term supply contracts, hedging instruments (approximately 70% of 2025 energy needs were reported as hedged), and strategic investments in energy efficiency and renewable self-generation, such as the PPA with Acciona Energía.7 However, unhedged portions or sharp, sustained increases in energy prices beyond contractual pass-through capabilities could still compress profitability.

Raw Material Costs and Supply: Similar to energy, the cost and availability of key raw materials (such as soda ash, sand, and limestone, as well as cullet for recycling) can be subject to inflation and supply chain disruptions. While Vidrala aims to pass on such cost increases, there can be a lag or incomplete recovery, affecting margins.

Production Interruptions: Glass manufacturing requires continuous furnace operation. Any unplanned downtime due to equipment failure, maintenance overruns, or labor issues can be costly in terms of lost production and fixed cost absorption.

Integration of Acquisitions: The recent large acquisition of Vidroporto in Brazil carries integration risks. Achieving projected synergies, aligning operational cultures, and navigating the specific business environment in Brazil are crucial for the success of this strategic expansion. Early performance in Q1 2025 indicated some challenges.

Market and Competitive Risks

Intense Competition: Vidrala faces strong competition from large global players like O-I Glass, Verallia, and Ardagh Group, all of whom have significant scale and resources. Competition also exists, albeit to a lesser extent given sustainability trends, from alternative packaging materials such as aluminum cans and plastics.

Demand Fluctuations: While demand for glass packaging is generally stable, it is not immune to economic cycles, shifts in consumer preferences (e.g., from wine to spirits or vice-versa), and inventory adjustments (destocking) by customers, as observed in 2023 and early 2024. A prolonged economic downturn could impact volumes.

Pricing Pressure: The presence of large, sophisticated customers and strong competitors can lead to pricing pressure, particularly for standardized products. Vidrala's ability to differentiate through service (Encirc model), quality, and innovation is key to maintaining pricing power.

Customer Concentration: With the top 10 customers accounting for approximately 35% of revenue, the loss or significant volume reduction from a key customer could have a material impact on Vidrala's financial results.

Financial Risks

Currency Risk: As an international company with significant operations in the UK (GBP) and Brazil (BRL), Vidrala is exposed to fluctuations in foreign currency exchange rates when translating results back into Euros. The company employs hedging strategies for GBP and aims for natural hedging in Brazil by using local cash flows to service local debt, but unhedged exposures or significant currency volatility can still affect reported earnings and cash flows.

Interest Rate Risk: A portion of Vidrala's debt may be at variable interest rates, exposing the company to rising interest costs in a tightening monetary environment. This risk is managed primarily through interest rate swaps to convert variable-rate debt to fixed rates.

Debt and Solvency: While current leverage is low, future large acquisitions or significant downturns in profitability could increase debt levels and associated financial risk. Compliance with debt covenants is also monitored.

ESG-Related Risks and Opportunities

Carbon Emissions and Regulatory Costs: The energy-intensive nature of glass production results in significant greenhouse gas emissions. Increasing carbon taxes, stricter emissions trading schemes, or other environmental regulations could elevate operating costs. Conversely, Vidrala's proactive investments in decarbonization and energy efficiency present an opportunity to lead in sustainable practices and potentially gain a competitive advantage.

Water Scarcity: Glass manufacturing consumes water. Increasing water scarcity in certain regions or stricter regulations on water use could pose operational challenges or increase costs. Vidrala has targets to improve water efficiency.

Geopolitical and Macroeconomic Factors

Global Economic Trends: Vidrala's performance is linked to overall economic activity, which influences consumer spending on food and beverages. Recessions or slow growth in key markets can dampen demand.

Trade Policies and Tariffs: Changes in international trade policies or the imposition of tariffs could affect Vidrala's cross-border operations or the cost of imported raw materials or exported finished goods. Management noted potential US tariffs could impact a small percentage (2-3%) of sales.

Geopolitical Instability: Events such as the conflict in Ukraine and tensions in the Middle East can disrupt global supply chains, impact energy prices, and create broader economic uncertainty, indirectly affecting Vidrala's operations and markets.

A thorough understanding and continuous monitoring of these risks are essential for any investment decision.

Valuation

Estimating the intrinsic value of Vidrala is crucial for determining if its current market price offers an attractive entry point for a YAINer, and this is why we will look at our usual metrics.

Given Vidrala's quality characteristics (strong market positions, good returns on capital, prudent management), we reckon these metrics are very attractive for long-term investors like YAINers.

Conclusions

Vidrala S.A. has demonstrated the characteristics of a durable and well-managed business operating within the fundamentally stable container glass industry. Its strategic evolution from a local Spanish manufacturer to a significant European player with a growing presence in Brazil has been marked by technological adoption, prudent acquisitions, and value-realizing divestments.

The company benefits from strong market positions in Iberia and the UK & Ireland, with the Encirc subsidiary's integrated "360-degree" service model providing a distinct competitive advantage. The container glass industry itself is supported by positive tailwinds from the sustainability agenda, favoring glass due to its recyclability and inertness. While the industry has high barriers to entry, Vidrala faces robust competition from large global peers, necessitating continuous operational excellence.

Management appears competent and shareholder-aligned, with significant insider ownership and a history of returning capital to shareholders through a growing dividend and opportunistic share buybacks. Capital allocation decisions have generally been strategic, focusing on strengthening core markets, expanding service offerings, and diversifying into growth regions while divesting non-core assets.

Vidrala could be an attractive long-term investment for YAINers if its shares can be acquired at a price that offers a significant margin of safety relative to a conservatively estimated intrinsic value. The company's quality characteristics – its moat, financial strength, and management competence – suggest it is likely to continue compounding shareholder value over time.

YAINers should focus on Vidrala's ability to maintain its returns on capital, grow its intrinsic value per share, and continue its disciplined approach to serving its customers and rewarding its shareholders. The key will be to acquire an ownership stake at a price that reflects a clear discount to its long-term earnings power and intrinsic worth.

1   https://www.vidrala.com/en/vidrala/about-us/history/ 

2  https://www.investing.com/news/transcripts/earnings-call-transcript-vidrala-q4-2024-shows-steady-growth-and-expansion-93CH-3898859 

3  https://www.verifiedmarketresearch.com/product/europe-glass-bottles-containers-market

4  https://feve.org/the-importance-of-the-container-glass-industry-for-the-eu/

5  https://www.globaldata.com/company-profile/vidrala-sa/competitors/

6  https://www.cnmv.es/webservices/verdocumento/ver?e=4TZdE8QTb5sh7DZturxWrqfqoTZheLsWaW8eg8EG1exQSRh0dt1K2vXNhAR3mLSV